Hindi Imposition or Just Hype? Delhi Speaks on the Language Debate! Street Talk | 3 Language Formula
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 апр 2025
- 3 Language Formula: Is Hindi really being imposed, or is it just another controversy? We hit Delhi’s streets to find out what people think about the language debate. Watch this fun and fiery vox pop with Charulata Biswas as Delhiites share their unfiltered opinions!
#3languageformula #hindiimposition #tamilnadulanguagerow #mkstalin #northvssouth
Production & Report: Charulata Biswas
Camera: Madhur Shyam
Edit: Meetesh Dixit
The Indian Express covers a wide spectrum of national and international news, including daily updates, political developments, election coverage, gadget and mobile reviews, technology updates, entertainment news, Bollywood trends, sports news and public opinions on daily topics.
The Indian Express's comprehensive coverage extends to global events, providing insightful analysis on international affairs. With a focus on both Indian and global perspectives, the Indian Express delivers top-notch editorial analysis and in-depth reporting. Stay informed with the latest news, trends, explained and expert views from India and around the world.
You can search us on RUclips by: @indianexpress, indian express, indian express newspaper today,indian express newspaper,indian express editorial analysis,indian express analysis,indian express analysis today,indian express,indian express news,the indian express newspaper analysis,the indian express,the indian express newspaper analysis today,the indian express editorial analysis,the indian express newspaper.
Stay Tuned To Indian Express For More Updates: indianexpress....
Watch Out Our Weekly Shows:
🡆 Political Pulse - • Political Pulse
🡆 Express Explained In 60 Seconds - • Express Explained In 6...
🡆 Zero Hour with Derek O' Brien - • Zero Hour with Derek O...
🡆 Indian Express Explained - • Indian Express Explained
🡆 UPSC Essentials- • UPSC ESSENTIALS: ART &...
#LatestNews #BreakingNews #EnglishNews
Subscribe to our Channel:
The Indian Express: goo.gl/RjJrX0
Subscribe to our Network Channels:
Jansatta (Hindi): / jansatta
Loksatta (Marathi): / loksatta
The Financial Express / financialexpress
Express Drives (Auto): / expressdrives
Inuth (Youth): / inuthdotcom
Indian Express Bangla: / indianexpressbangla
Indian Express Punjab: / @indianexpresspunjab
Indian Express Malayalam: / iemalayalam
Indian Express Tamil: / @indianexpresstamil
Connect with us:
Facebook: / indianexpress
Twitter: / indianexpress
Indian Express App: indianexpress.c...
Official Website: indianexpress....
I don’t know why people are telling that Hindi is Raj basha..Tamil originated ages before Hindi and we have great literatures and history..everyone loves their mother tongue so they should consider it as rajbasha and keep it to themselves
@@harinikumar8170 Hindi and English are official languages of India
They are not politically, constitution aware. Literally sleeping while awake
@@KarthickP-q3u According to constitution, Hindi and English are official languages.
Modi government is not forcing anyone to learn Hindi. They are asking to learn any 2 languages apart from their mother tongue. That applies to every state . Tamil Nadu is not special
@harshit5803
Brother, I understand the video is taken in a light hearted manner
In a federal structure, a State has the right to diagree with Union government policy
It's about standard. Telugu Tamil etc are cringe that's why no foreigners learn these but they learn Hindi because they know which is valuable and which is useless
All those who said South Indians should learn Hindi, but will not learn a South Indian language, that's Hindi imposition folks!!!!
There are crpto pakistanis.
That's why singers like Arijit Singh and Shreya Ghoshal are not from South 😂😂😂😂
true north is just illiterate to even comprehend what you said.
Lol go outside, Biharis who entering telengana hyderabad are speaking telugu fluently with couple of years and you telugu ego losers can't learn simple hindi. Your iq speaks volumes
@@stephenhawking2458that's why those musicians r not getting any Oscar award🤣😂🤣
Hindi is not our national language. They need to understand this first
But it's the most spoken language in India...except TN almost all other places u can manage with it.....
@@surya371-d4c Those people who are saying "Hindi is our national language" are the ones who do not know their own country but have only false pride. They will not put any effort to understand the sentiment and culture of other region but will try to impose theirs. If they want a country which speak only Hindi why don't they go and unite with Hindi speaking Paekistan!s.
I am from North-East and I am with the tamil sentiments.
@PhoenixFury10 pak is urdu speaking not hindi
But we need common language
@@vimalvijayan001 Those pak crickters don't speak Hindi? The pak crickter must be more petriotic about India than people from TN just because they speak your "National Lang"
Many North Indians believe that Hindi is the national language because their design is shaped that way.
Lets redesign....lol
madrasisiis keep believing both hindi and english are official languages
@@KarthickP-q3u haha😂😂
@satishkumarpalani Are you blind or deaf? Haven't you heard? Many people in this video said they know Hindi and their regional mother language as well. Knowing or learning Hindi won't make people lose their grip on their mother tongue.
Yes 10000000000% true
The Solution is simple.... Don't enforce any language....If you feel you require to learn any language....learn it....if you don't don't
Yes leave it to students and parents
Politicians like Modi (who can at best speak teleprompter-English) will cry !
Yay this should have been done this will not only encourage people to learn multiple languages but also help those languages which are on the verge of extinction
Thats What TN is Saying
BJP is having problems because they want to make india same as china. Look where china is now, that's what they want. But india will not be a democracy then. It will be an authoritarian government.
Only HINDI isn't INDIA. INDIA is plural, multicultural & diverse on society.
Listen. Hindi is important , because it will help you people only to communicate with rest of the nation . And who is prohibiting you guys to learn or speak in Tamil ? But please put some effort and learn Hindi . My honest advice . Cuz if you all go on arguing over it , it may happen that you all waste much of your energy doing nothing , instead , could have learnt some Hindi. (It's not about pride and ego , it's about survival and communication) . Rest is upto you'll , use your presence of mind and go ahead on the top of world , rather fightng amongst yourselves only.
Nowadays, everyone posts their opinions in the comment section mostly in English! So in the multilingual Indian Union, English can be the connecting language. Moreover, English is used more here than Hindi.
@@whywhy04because of our effect and present of mind we arre Ai Advisor to trump and musk
we created world first micro satalight
,isro scientist
ceo of google , zoho,hcl
we have successsfull p eople around the world
noble price winners
also in nasa our scientist are there
this is what we do not wasting time putting effort on useslless things like hindi people do
if you want to be successfull dont follow advice of hindi people follow what tamil people do
@@whywhy04Listen , english is better option than hindi as a link language
Yet you are using english. 😂@@whywhy04
Only two language, mother tongue and English.
Only one language which is Mother tongue even in CBSE and other languages can be learnt from outside like Spoken English or HIndi or French or German
Ooh You love English that is foreign. But not like Hindi which is BHARTIYA language
@@rudrakshsrivastava1984 See the Pakistan people condition, they did not learnt English, what happened after 50 years. see their economy. check Bangladesh also.
only Foreign companies are giving jobs to Indians indirectly, to perform that job well, we need English..
@jaykay5552 yes what happened with south indian people in America. They killed them.
@@rudrakshsrivastava1984 do you know the technology and things from a motorcycle to mobile and medicines are a product and an Innovation of another person from another country. Do you leave all those things because it's not created or invented by Indian's right
Asking this question to already majority Hindi speaking people of Delhi is like discussing malaria problems with mosquitos itself, obviously they are going to support Hindi.
😂😂😂 Spot on, bro !
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@vishnups173 haaa
😂😂😂
@@vishnups173 🤣💗👌👏
Question is not about :
"Why not learn hindi?" It's "Why should we learn Hindi?"
I'm a tamil guy from Bangalore I've studied 2nd language Kannada (Regional) & 3rd hindi.
Hindi doesn't help in anyway with my career/ not helpful generally.
Is anybody telling you to learn Hindi ?
The moment you come out of your cocoon and visit any other state, which you will, if you're not a villager, you'll know the importance of communication and having a common tongue like hindi is acceptable in almost all states other than some down south.
@kumarhrithik8658 When we have good job opportunity that pays well here, other then vacation why would we visit north indian states.?
So it ain't mandatory to learn Hindi when we're going to visit hindi speaking states rarely..
@@kumarhrithik8658 Nearly 7.97 lakh students in the Uttar Pradesh - known as the Hindi heartland - have failed in Hindi in the UP Secondary Board examinations for class 10 and 12, the results of which were announced on Saturday.
And you expect south students to learn Hindi. Ask the Hindi speaking students to learn one language properly
According to these people those who don't know hindi were not Indian. So it feels like we south indians were not Indian.
Thank you
No one say that .
@@gv1206 Happy to go, choose the Singapore way, anytime. Is the Union government ok with it?!
@@gv1206 Happy to go, choose the Singapore way. ❤️Is the Union government okay with it?
lol…. These guys don’t realize that our country in at least 5000 years old and Tamil is atleast 2700 years old , Telugu is atleast 2100 years old, Kanada is atleast 2000 years old and Malayalam is atleast 1000 years old. Hindi is only 200 years old . We have been Indians long long before somebody even imagined the word Hindustani… forget Hindi.
Hindi is not a national language
😂😂 national language telgu
@@rajKahar-vu1oc Modi taking hindi only speakers to Trump's press meeting, and they spoke Dinglish (The English which even Indians cannot understand) to Trump was the funniest ever. 🤣🤣🤣
And Telugu is nothing just shitty useless language
If the two languages policy is taught properly, I repeat if taught properly there will be no need for this debate. Everyone would know their own mother tongue and English. We can communicate in English when required.
@@mathivananmathi6982Hindi is a must for any Indian
Why should we take the burden of learning 3 languages. 2 languages are enough - local and english languages. I from Northeast india support south india❤. Totally Biased people😂
Exactly....
@@Indigenousaxom you learned Korean ?? K drama watchers
That guy is scooter said he said he will not even attempt to learn any south languages. That is e actly what the people in the South feel with hindi.
Hindi is beautiful ❤
@@RandhaiyaDoesn't look beautiful to South
தமிழ் is wonderful language. No comparision to it
That's the reality. If you look at the same stats of NEP in North, not one state has selected south Indian languages even when people come to south for better quality of life. As a south Indian, I speak quite a few languages including Hindi and I don't go to maharashtra or Delhi and say, "you need to know kannada/konkani/Malayalam coz that's the only language I know"!! I am not imposing my language on them and I think they should also respect regional languages. Soo many govt job exams are either in Hindi or English.. localities are losing out on jobs because they are at disadvantage here. If this is not imposition, I am not sure what is.
Only he is saying but In my family many member know telugu can speak and write
I am from Andhra pradesh we want 2 language policy don't want 3 language policy.
Lots of your Telegu biddas are supporting hindi, the nizams language.
@reecosmicatomsb8576 nizam are migrated from central Asia we are indians why do u support them south indian states have their own languages and we have one linking language english why do we take more burden.
@KoteswaraRaoVeginati-w3z you read my comments. Lots of telegu biddas are supporting hindi
@@reecosmicatomsb8576 nizams language is urdu not hindi...
@@KoteswaraRaoVeginati-w3z
State government can revoke it if people are United and protest. Remember Jallikattu 🐂
See, no north Indians are willing to learn kannada then why should we learn hindi..
She is saying we should learn
@boopathinavaneethansubrama455 that's never.. hindi is a forigen language created by mughals.. so ban hindi
Because we love to learn telugu not other
Ok saar 🤡
👍 true
Hindi is not our National language
Read article 351
@@professionalsmunch3541 🤣🤣🤣 no one in south India accepted that article
that's that article was pushed away from south 2 time before 1970
same will be happen again
@@professionalsmunch3541 No national language as such for India. English and all 22 languages in Eighth Schedule are official languages.
Plz make it,if you can,lol😂@@-ma
@@KarthickP-q3u Hindi and English are only official languages.
Everryone prefers hindi because its their mother tongue. But no one understands that down South India for a person from Tamil Nadu, Tamil is their mother tongue.
Why we learn forse fully hindi we are not hate any language hame chayiye tu seekega hindi chodo other South Indian language sekho bolega tum seekhega Kya khana kitna chayiye utna khayega jayda julm kiya tu ulti ajayega 😜🤪🤣😃😀
Where you read this story. Hindi was not anyone's mother tongue. It was introduced in the late 1860s mixture of Sanskrit and Hindustani but the script is Devanagari. There was also a mixture of Hindustani and urudu languages but it was destroyed. Brahmins cunning plan to impose Hindi and Sanskrit on Indian people and destroy the history of other languages which have been happening since the 1860s.
Why unnecessary imposition of 3 languages when you can learn your mother tongue and English for good future.
.
@@thangap200why to bring Brahmins in this discussion, Brahmins of south don't know Hindi , in fact 90 percent of literary works in Tamil , Telugu , kannada , malayalam were written by Brahmins
Whose mother tongue is hindi?
@Aratiii06 Many people use hindi as a mother tongue. any doubt.
As a Bengali from West Bengali I support two language policy, Bengali and English. don't need to hindi ...আমি গর্বিত, আমি বাঙালি, জয় বাংলা🔥❤ ✊
@@akashsaha129 you are a kanglu refugee
English don't need foreign countries will interfare
Beta sikhni to padegi , nahi to mammi pant utaar ke sikhayegi 😂😂
@@whywhy04Gutka khor🤡🤡😂😂😂
😂😂this is only your thought even I am in an engineering college and my friend is bengali.her hindi is much better.if you don't want to learn Hindi that' s your problem.
The people of Tamil Nadu will never surrender to the tyranny and unreasonable demands of the fascist Hindutva government of BJP!
Right now fascists like Stalin are ruling Tamil Nadu
lol i agree BJP is fascist but so is DMK, their whole politics run on hindi hate( now bjp has given them chance by imposing 2 lang even knowing TN is lang sensitive state), brahmin hate, Dravidian nationalism..just one good thing DMK is secular else both are same side of coin.
@@naruto6918 All parties are corrupt..
but you love fascist pentacostal government DMK, Congress etc.?
Stupid spotted 😂
North Indians will never understand how Tamilians love their language. It's the bonding factor, hindu muslim, Christians and all parties will support this. They will never allow Hindi in TN. If you don't understand, it's a irony, this problem will stay.
Centre should implement president rule thr then
Periyar said tamil is a barbarian language, but we vote for them.
Ambedkar views over Islamic laws and still we support illegal structures on hindu worship areas for centuries....
Vijay's implementation of 3 language policy in his educational institution and opposing NEP. Secularism in USA freed church from government whereas in India the maulvis get income from state collected temple tax which is opposite to islamic laws.
Temple priest get no benefits.
Converts such as Muslims in slums are having 12 children per family and enjoying the animal life by hindus income tax payers money 🤑💰.
Christians who got converted still use hindu names for reservations or 🤑💰.
Freebies of some impotent so called leaders are destroying people's will to live on their own.
This misfortune people are in administration without any qualification....
They fool you for their interest that's why temples land is sold by your current government.I think how foolish you are? 😂😂😂
If the temples of tamilnadu were destroyed how would you protect your culture.Temple is a source of language, culture, technology,great architecture of india .First, protect your temple then your language because if you protect your temple ultimately your language will be protected.
They wants to destroy the language bond of Tamilians. So that they can divide people based on religion. Then only they can get some seat in Tamilnadu.
Was an insightful video!
I am a Kannadiga who knows Hindi and have been living in Delhi-NCR for last 3 years. I speak Hindi and have no issues with it.
The amount of people telling that Hindi needs to be learnt for their convenience is shocking, why should we put in efforts for your convenience?
Yeah the problem is Kids are dragged into this , like their education will get affected a lot of they started learning these many languages along with science and social lol bruh. Like they should learn the language of the land they go for work in rather expect the people of that land to speak their language, and the thing is they in turn are not ready to learn southern language rather promote Sanskrit. Like wild bro this is colonial mindset being promoted
Yes, very true
The constitution doesn't force any lndians to learn Hindi but the BJP is forcing the indians to speak Hindi language,Let lndians chose which language is best for him or her to learned.Never force anyone.
Constititution recommends Central govt to promote hindi lang, just bjp doing forcefully while congress do softly. Centre official lang is hindi and English(added due to cry from south).
Sayad congress ke time me bhi log hindi hi bolte the bhai ye sab political noutanki he😅 he
@@naruto6918 not cry from south, fight from south
@ yes it was large scale protest, that’s why congress backed off, loll
@@naruto6918Where backed off in their education policy Hindi was compulsory
National food make it Gutka
More pride, revenue and can easily decorate the nation. Majority wise it’s more too..
😂😂😂
😂😂
lmao yes and national bird is crow and national animal is street dogs...all are majority
Bruh 😂
And natinal bird should be Crow😂
I am from TamilNadu we support 2 language policy Tamil, English. ❤
And what about the other states bro ?
English is more than language it's a business and machine language.its really help to get jobs.. Every one should know thier mother tounge and another should be english if anyone interested can learn punjabi or hindi or Rajasthani or marathi or bengali but govt should not waste fund third language whatever it is .In UP and Bihar if telugu or tamil teached them as third language..do you feel it's valid similar way for South people don't want hindi or bengali or urudu that's unnecessary for them that's it ..Govt should focus on science and technology @KochinBrothers
Only Telugu.. no Tamil
@@arp589 what you want???? Why we want to learn your telungu in my state..
Try to learn malvani
Just because they know only Hindi, they want everyone to learn only Hindi. This is a lame reason.
Bharat doesn't mean hindi and hindi doesn't mean bharat.
See the audacity of these people!!!! "Tamil seekhna Muskil hai" is a valid point for them but south indians cant say the same thing about hindi!
The uneducated lady has more brains than the other so called educated crowd!
So lastly, discussing "hindi imposition" with people who speak only hindi and have no knowledge about history and diversity & don't even know which southern state speaks which language ..is just mocking the whole issue of language debate!!
From where we can study tamil easily any recommendation
@@adityakushwFrom FM Nirmala Sitharaman, u can learn tamil.
@ 🤣🤣 ok
RUclips 😊@@adityakushw
Many of the people who were interviewed has subconsciously forgot that they have sidelined their Mother tongue (Punjabi/Marathi/Gujarati/Marwari/ Braj Bhasha / Methi) , which would erode the lead to language extinction with in 2-3 generations.
Force them to learn some south indian language 😂😂.. we are indians rt? Learn some our language and come to our states , when we come to your states to sell panipuri we will learn hindi.
You can sell Jalebi, it is the same as your language 😂😂.
Sombhar chatani sambhar are advantage for you.
@vijaykumaryadav2168 ok, where is your panipuri shop in banaglore?
You will find that shop, where people like it so much.😂
@@vijaykyadav2168 Leave us alone, we don't need your language!
@amitdas6347 tha same place where people like it so much. In Bangalore
North indians thinks that Hindi is our national language... We must educate the people that Hindi is not a national language..it's one of those indian languages
All north Indian compulsory learn any south Indian languages
first they should engish nd then come to 3rd language
Why North Indian People learn south Indian language ???
First you learn hindi
@@nimishmothghare bcoz u ppl are only selling panipuri's in south
@@nimishmothghare lol 😂 when you come to sell pani puri in south, you should sell in south languages or English.
@@nimishmothghare Modi taking hindi only speakers to Trump's press meeting, and they spoke Dinglish (The English which even Indians cannot understand) to Trump was the funniest ever. 🤣🤣🤣
So, moral of the story hindi is just imposed on rest of india like spat of guthka...
Even those who lost their language like maithilis, bhojpuris and brajs are in forefront to spat hindi.
these lang are not independent vro, they are dialects just like Archaic English, thy thou etc They can never survive without govt support, distinct identity, systematic support..Bhojpuri is not even formal lang.
@@naruto6918 But dialect of whom ???
Hindi ??? 😆
If you want to destroy your arrogance just do research on maithili, you'll learn about vidyapati and how ancient these languages and culture is.
@@arindam4185 where is maithali written , why is not even in google translate ? why bihari dont use it or promote it, why they use hindi,? why do you even care about others ? no maithali speakers are crying, they dont care if lang remains or die, it is bound to happen with globalisation and cross state migration
Many of the people who were interviewed has subconsciously forgot that they have sidelined their Mother tongue (Punjabi/Marathi/Gujarati/Marwari/ Braj Bhasha / Methi) , which would erode the lead to language extinction with in 2-3 generations.
People are so free that they are fighting over language language is just a way of communication me being gujarati i know hindi a little bit marathi and english as well with my local language no one is imposing hindi but if u know hindi u still can communicate in states like maharshtra gujarat uttar pradesh haryana delhi infact other than those 1/2 state almost everyone can understand hindi learning hindi will open the job aspect all over india seeing the outrage by especially tamil and kannada people donu think if u come to northern state u will get respect??
And NEP tells for three languages so a person from bihar who is a maithili speaker can know Maithili hindi as well as English
And it all depands movies like oushpa 2 kgf chapter 2 earns so much money because they were multilingual so instead of fighting over language just kearn the language
Hindi is not National Language.....just official language because that time most of people didn't know English....except South India....😂
@krishnaragu327 Well, check the linguistic data and find out what percentage of people in South India know English. Only 15% of the people in South India know English. How can you say this? 65% of the people of South India still live in villages and you are saying that the entire South India knows to speak English. Then this is your mistake. And whoever speaks South Indian English, their accent is so amazing that it seems like they are original English speakers. Hahaha 😆
non veg should be the national dish as everyone will get the required protein vitamin as the prices of vegetables are sky rocketing
😂❤
Non veg is free?😅
Always time thise type of example not work well. For eg. Sex is requirement for reproduction therefore all are equal.😂😂😂 this type of example are illogical
Super
@@subhendukumar-l7c so if most population speak a language means it can be compelled on other that is logical... If English is also learnt by North Indian states why need another language? Give a logical statement... If all are equal abolish caste. Give a solid evidence. If hindi belt region is developed so well show me the numbers in GRoss enrollment ratio in higher education.. How hindi helped in GDP... Show me the logical statistics simply say so...
That’s the supremacy “IF YOU LIVE IN INDIA YOU SHOULD LEARN HINDI!!”
They think India means only north India 😂
No not all some people's ok bro ,as a north indian i know ok
1:27 Indian express ❌ Hindi express ✅.. How confident they are all of them are knows Hindi even it's a English media. 😢
18:37 the perfect citizen of India. ❤ Every citizen should be like him.
Great Tamilnadu education. 😌❤️❤️
The rotten egg of India . No one should be like him or else the nation will futher be divided . 😂
@@Nawongyonten-yp4fz Justus sirrrrrrr 😂
North Indians don't learn any language other than hindi.
But south is burdened with Hindi in the name of national unity.
North Indiane already apni bhashaon ke uper Hindi ko rkha hai desh ke liye
@@shanusingh3139 Desh ke liye, aap bhi apni bhashaon ke upar hamare bhashaon bei rakh dijkje, Telugu Kannada Malayalam Tamil
Learning 3 language is an unnecessary burden for students, i struggle with Hindi and Manipuri during my highschool days and it really affect my grades.
Same here
English shall be link language of India.
90% people cannot speak English but most Indians can speak Hindi (As a first or second language).
@@professionalsmunch3541 most of the indian means bimaru states only
ok ok
@@professionalsmunch3541 Give basic education to all indians. They will know english. No other option.
@@GamerOne_me wrong
@@rahulsadventure7105 it will take 50 years
To be Indian, it doesn't mean they need to know hindi. I hope the hindians get it in their brains.
Hindi is not required. Why to spend money on it. Only English required. What is the use for me.
Delhi people will support hindi😮.
Only last guy have a point and rest of the people just have not clue what they talk about.
They are not clueless most of them are being biased
@@praveenkumarvelraj8416 The last guy was educated, whereas the rest were influenced by whatsapp groups.
Tamil is our national language. English is the link language.
@@striker44 bengali is sweet language . I love bengali and hindi both language.
there's no national language!
Telugu is better than tamil . Tulus hate Tamilians
😂😂
Ancient language
These people are happy to belittle their mother tongue and give up their culture 😂 in order to protect Hindi...
Hindi is not our national language
Hindi is not our national language, it's an official language along with English
Not india 22 official language
Inner india so many country union called india
Just why language is dengerous topic @@ponnaanbu3491
Its hypocrisy of hindi belt..
If three language is implemented than
3 language language should be from three different language family ..
But bro, Hindi and English are from the same language family.
The hypocrisy of so called Tamilians is that they can speak English which is 1000 years newer than Tamil but can't accept Hindi
@@bishalkryadav4962no, can't accept. Why will they accept?
@@bishalkryadav4962 Hindi has no inherent value in it, whereas English has inherent value to it. Bhai, tum logon ka dimag gobar se bhara hua hai kya?. Hindi seekhne se kya milega hame, other than making lives of Hindi people migrating to South. Hindi really is a burden on school kids. The Hindi states have low literacy rates, which means they don't know their own language, shouldn't you guys be focusing on making yourself literate first before you impose Hindi on others?
Nowadays, everyone posts their opinions in the comment section mostly in English! So in the multilingual Indian Union, English can be the connecting language. Moreover, English is used more here than Hindi.
It's not about learning Hindi or any other language-it's about coming together on a common platform for unity. If you know Hindi, you can communicate across all of North India. While there are several languages spoken in the northern region, people still find common ground to sustain communication.
In contrast, South India lacks a single unifying language, and the resistance to a common medium of communication seems misplaced. The entire nation should strive for a common linguistic identity, and Hindi serves that purpose effectively. Moreover, people across the country are willing to learn English because it brings economic benefits, yet some in South India refuse to speak even in English, often to alienate or intimidate non-speakers. This behavior amounts to nothing but pure exclusion and linguistic bullying.
Absolutely brilliant street talk! What’s next? Asking fish if they feel like they’re being forced to swim in water?
lol yeah! They are asking imposers if they are comfortable with imposing on others!
@@rukminitanjore8473😂😂
Well said bro
15:16 awesome well said chennai bro too
U r saying they dont forget their own mother language, then tell me how languages died according to census.
Census take one , lots of place people just say " hindi " plus its not like we dont want others language to recognised , we still got the options to pick language
@@fnmidas7936 Man you have seen examples here in this video. Where he cant speak brach basha but his father. A language can easily die through generations. If it is not needed and no art forms in that language. Surely in 2 generation all their grand childs will not speak his mother tounge,
@@fnmidas7936 That the reality. If you give focus to one language and promote only one and you don't boost art and cinema in that language. People of future generations will not be interested in that language. They will feel ashamed. We don't need 3 language in this modern world. Studing a computer language is 1000 times better than studying a language. As our minister said. 3 language policy is flop model. And hard to implement everywhere. If it is successful. State who followed that should be successful than us. Or atleast should be well verse in two languages. See the cences of people knowing two languages in various state. You will understand a little
Many of the people who were interviewed has subconsciously forgot that they have sidelined their Mother tongue (Punjabi/Marathi/Gujarati/Marwari/ Braj Bhasha / Methi) , which would erode the lead to language extinction with in 2-3 generations.
There's NO MEXICAN LANGUAGE 😂 IT'S SPANISH spoken in Mexico
I think people should be aware that is hindi is not a national language ironically
Hindi isn't national language. However it's spoken nationally as it's a language which persons from all states can understand. Will you be able to understand if I spoke with you in my native language?
@@abbys777 sorry to tell u ,may be u maynot know the fact that hindi is not spoken nationally....infact i don't understand neither Hindi nor your native language.
I could speak well in my native language and English .
If i need to learn the other languages i am always open if the situation demands...
@priyadharshinic93 Which would are you living in? This isn't Gulf, Russia, China or Japan. Hindi is widely spoken all over India. It's the people in South who are opposing it. My mother tongue is Marathi, however I can speak in Hindi. If your native language is Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, Tulu, etc. then how am I supposed to communicate with you if I don't know English? In my State I had Marathi and Hindi during PUC exams and in college. What's the problem in learning an additional language to communicate with others? Why did you learn English? You should have boycotted that too.
@abbys777 if i come to any of the hindi predominantly speaking state i should definitely learn hindi ....i am not against learning hindi ...what i am saying is that the idea of generalization of learning hindi is not suit for south state .i am glad that u know many South Languages name.
U know hindi, u can communicate in hindi atleat 1 person in a day ..
Suppose i tell u i learnt hindi ....i am just waiting for any hindi speaking person to communicate in my state and refresh my neurons...
In your perspective hindi is widely spoken by many people...its not atleast not in my state ..
If u come any of the south states u should learn their language if u are not good in English ...
And I AM AN INDIAN .MY COUNTRY IS VERY DIVERSE 💯.
@@priyadharshinic93 You are being stubborn like your State people. If you start telling other States to learn your language then they too will tell you to learn their language. It's not possible for someone all of a sudden to learn any language. Will you learn Chinese, Japanese, Russian or Arabic if you are visiting their Country on a short trip? Bringing your ego in between won't solve the language barrier. Although diverse I am trying to connect with you but if you show attitude then I too shall loose interest in it. As per your comment you are an Indian. So does that make others and me an Outsider?
@The Indian Express, @Charulata Biswas
Delhi is a dumb choice. Ask the same question with the people at Tiruchirappalli, Madurai, Coimbatore, Chennai or even Bengaluru. You'll get to know that the Union Govt tries to push/force it on State Govt.
This is not funny. Handle this with sensitivity care.
And you'll get to know how Delhi was the worst choice.
Delhi is worst choice because your biased wasn't confirmed here, bigot
@@KarthickP-q3u little bit correct.
But not completely.
Because if this question asked in Chennai, bengaluru etc then everybody will say hindi is imposed.
Delhi is perfect place to answer this because in Delhi there are too many people live from different regions and language.
The mistake from journalist is that she is asking this question from wrong person, person who speaks Hindi.
She should asked this question from different language speaking people.
@@himanshuratwal5826 @himanshuratwal5826
Brother, The charge against the ruling Union Government at both the houses of Parliament , last 3 days, is that, they're trying to push/force their Three Language Policy on Tamil Nadu Government, their people, when they've their own Two Language policy since the 1960s, which is working well for them since inception. That's exactly what TN MPs are fighting for at Parliament.
As an honest Newspaper, Indian Express should go to the ground level in Tamil Nadu, and do the fact check. Isn't it?
Let me play Devil's advocate. May be the TN MPs are not representing the real opinion of the people of Tamil Nadu. The Indian Express, journalist must find on their own.
Coming to Delhi, did the Delhi MPs block the Parliament proceedings, was it a burning issue in Delhi? Do you've the data of people living in Delhi, but came from different regions? If so, please share for the public. Happy to have positive conversations.
Exactly
@@himanshuratwal5826 Delhi os not as diverse as banglore.
Please interview educated and learned people for a rational and logical discussion.
Sikh bjp wala😂😂😂
He is Pakistani wannabe… he wants India to have the same policy as pak
@ProsperProsper-z7dthat's why south india is becoming violent towards these north migrants
Hindi hasn’t been imposed on people in Delhi and Tamil hasn’t been imposed on people in TN. What’s the point of this survey? 😂 It’s like an interviewer going around in southern states asking the locals if their mother tongue has been imposed or not?! 😅 The point to take away here is “None” of these people from North said they want a South Indian language as 3rd Language. And you want the South to have Hindi compulsory. 😂😂
😂😂
I was thinking the same😂 thing
Exactly. She is such a moron! I can’t even!!
Thats y still hindi states r not developed bcs they r logicless handi 🐖🐖 speakers 😂😂
Well said average chindians language people 😂😂
In this video, one or two people say that tamil nadu people should learn hindi right?
So they are Many hindi peoples working in Tamil nadu right? Will they learn Tamil?
Why am I saying this? Tell the Hindi people to first learn Tamil and then the Tamil people will learn Hindi
because Tamil is the mother of Hindi
Mr Singh you are from Punjabi I suppose. You lost your Punjabi language to Hindi and what if tomorrow the majority of the Indians say that you should not wear turban because majority do not wear turban. Will that be acceptable to you and other Sikh members of the country?
On a Daily basis, there is preaching in gurdwara - speak punjabi in your homes , with your children. Don't forget your mother tongue.
BUT these people go to gurdwara,
they just Talk with each other, don't listen to anything.
And see the girl @ 8:22
she is a Hindu girl of punjabi background, she is total😢 unaware of what damage has been done. She is ripped off her mother tongue and still proudly giving a nationalist excuse.
Since north indians eat roti chapati you cannot force south people to eat the same. We have our own choice. We south people don't want to learn hindi because we dont want it so dont force it. our literacy rate and state GDP is way above any hindi speaking state. So what is the point in learning hindi. Instead of learning hindi we can invest the time in learning some software language like python, Java or some scripting language. This will help us to get a job. Does hindi exist 800 years before ? We are happy with our 5000 years old Tamil. Hindi is the mixture of foreign language you can google it your self. Like any other indian language hindi is just an official language not an National language.
South Indians are smart, and we won't accept hindi imposition. So don't waste time promoting hindi in south india. We are happy with our mother tongue.
But roti chapati is rajyakhana
/s
People are so free that they are fighting over language language is just a way of communication me being gujarati i know hindi a little bit marathi and english as well with my local language no one is imposing hindi but if u know hindi u still can communicate in states like maharshtra gujarat uttar pradesh haryana delhi infact other than those 1/2 state almost everyone can understand hindi learning hindi will open the job aspect all over india seeing the outrage by especially tamil and kannada people donu think if u come to northern state u will get respect??
And NEP tells for three languages so a person from bihar who is a maithili speaker can know Maithili hindi as well as English
And it all depands movies like oushpa 2 kgf chapter 2 earns so much money because they were multilingual so instead of fighting over language just kearn the language
@mbalawins : That's the main problem of your people , first they don't know something , then they fight over their half knowledge like illiterate.
Everybody in south knows that through NEP they can get rid of Hindi compulsion. Also they get ample of languages to learn by choice. Eventhough all showing like as if they don't know anything about NEP. They doing everything quite gradually . First start with Hindi is imposed fom decades, then NEP will impose hindi, now each and every day new theories .Whole north india is poor and illiterate in their most beautiful dream.
Now., let's talk about Hindi, old shuddh Hindi is as old as prakrit. First use of Old hindi found around
10th C.E I.e 3000 yr. ago. At that time it's name was not Hindi.
Before Centuries ago of when Modern Hindi start developing , Local, regional languages of north are using e.g Awadhi : 1st use of Awadhi found in " Ramcharitmanas" which is written around 16th C.E I.e around
3600 yr.
Modern Hindi developed as Hindistani/Hindvi during islamic rule in india , i.e around 1000 A.D
There are some data statewise to open your eyes and mind. Regarding GDP & Education.
Gst collection 2024 in crores
1.Maharashtra. 37,600
2.Karnataka. 15,970
3.Gujarat. 13,300
4.UttarPradesh. 12,290
5.Tamilnadu. 12,210
6.Haryana. 12,160
7.Delhi. 07772
8.WestBengal. 07290
9.Telangana. 06236
Let's see how educated is north india.
Statewise data of literacy in (%) 2023.
1.Kerala. 96.2%
2.Lakshdweep. 92.2%
3.Mizoram. 91.5%
4.Delhi. 88.7%
5.Tripura. 87.7%
6.Uttrakhand. 87.6%
7.Goa. 87.4%
8.Daman& Diu. 87.0%
9.Himachal. 86.6%
10.Puducherry. 86.5%
11.Chandigarh. 86.4%
12. A&N island. 86.2%
13.Assam. 85.9%
14.Maharashtra. 84.8%
15.Punjab. 83.7%
16.Tamilnadu. 82.9%
17. Gujarat. 82.4%
18.Sikkim. 82.2%
19.WestBengal. 80.5%
20.Haryana. 80.4%
21.Nagaland. 80.1%
22.Manipur. 79.8%
23.Dadra & 77.6%
Nagar Haveli
24.J&K. 77.3%
25.Odisha. 77.3%
26.Chhattisgarh. 77.3%
27.Karnataka. 77.2%
28.Meghalaya. 75.4%
29.Jharkhand. 74.3%
30.MadhyaPradesh. 73.7%
31.UttarPradesh. 73.0%
32. Telngana. 72.8%
33. Bihar. 70.9%
34.Rajasthan. 69.7%
35.Arunanchal. 66.9%
Pradesh
36.AndhraPradesh. 66.4%
Now you might get the answer , who us literate & who is not.
@@immoralAryan Like Pakistan tried to unite Bangladesh by imposing Urdu ?
South indians learn when they go North. but its the Nirthies who is immigeating south should learn south langague.
No means NO. do you understand simple English?
People here in TN love to learn English, because of the nature of job we will be into. The coding language is in English. What is the Greatest you have achieved with Hindi that we need to learn it. What is the use? Just because you feel comfortable while coming to TN, should we learn Hindi? What kind of logic is this?
Ask in south india
Even this sold out media know that it doesn't works in south India to brain wash like northies 😅
In Tamil nadu 2 language policy works well.... Top institutions are from Tamil nadu and globally they are in higher position..
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yes , You are right 👍 Tamilians 👑
Only Ignorant people can say that the whole India can speak Hindi. Some North Indians even complaint that in Kerala and Tamil Nadu people do not know Hindi. They are under the impression that Hindi is spoken all over the world. Now many labors from UP, and Bihar, come to Kerala for Job and learn Malayalam and speak Malayalam very well.
Three bullets bjp had .. 1. religion - did not work … 2. language - Tamil woke up everyone … 3. Delimitation- we have lot of time …
Super
@@imtiazcs3421That doesn't mean Congress is heaven.. they are worse when it comes to minority appeasement.
Fake profile alert
@@imtiazcs3421 better than minority appeasement
Another propaganda
First teach those people what imposition means, I don't think these people know what imposition is ...
😂😂
what a clown you are. You are an actually illiterate bro not them 😂😂
@@ashokbatakala absolutely, I think the north indian should take a compulsory alternative language (it may be any other language be it axomiya-bengali-odia or even the mnipuri-mizo-naga or the decan languages like marathi-Carnnar-tamizh-telegu) course along with a classical language (old tamil/sanskrit)
Then they will realise the importance of other languages.
Bengali bsda should keep quiet.
You know every IIT has Hindi cell which has so much power. And IIT teaching sanskrit. But not regional language. You know in bihar around 1970 hindi was decelared as the state only official, when 90 % bihari dont know hindi. Noe see the language of bihar. New generation are not learning their mother toungue. Same may happen.
Yes You are In India. Learn Kannada Tamil Telugu Malyalam Marathi. Why these North Indians trying to promote Hindi over ours. We individual states have population compared to countries. Have basic Common sense
this video is creating narrative, north Indian people dont know even one language perfectly, we will learn hindi when we come to northen states, if you come to Bangalore or Chennai , please learn Kannada and Tamil respectively
we know 3 language better than u😂
No to any local language,only hindi
@@PraakashRanjannno to any thing have beef
@@jawan451 Meanwhile the three languages: Maithili, Bhojpuri and Hindi with little variation lol. It's like you saying I know how to write block letters and cursive letters
@@PraakashRanjann No to Hindi, only local language and English
You study 100 language in school don't study maths, science, social science.
Foolish interview.
It's funny how we proudly say to the whole World that "there is no other country like India, that is very UNITED in diversity!!" Where is the Unity here?!!
People who settled down & work in any Indian state, also pay all kinds of taxes & contribute to the development of that State!! Benefits are mutual !! No body settles down in any States for free!!
Why should India get dividend by State or language?!! We all are Indians
Then why show racism on language?
We Indians should respect all cultures & celebreate together!!
Any state can become a seperate country (getting divided & cut off from India due to language barrier), in future!! Now same happening in few more states.
If India gets divided by Language barrier, Next Generation will be in trouble!!
HINDI (not Urdu) is chosen as our Rashtra Bhasha because, there need to be atleast 1 language to solve language barrier problem ie. proper communication & keep all States in India United.
Sanskrit is not made our National language because, non-Hindus will have problem with it. If all States will start this, gradually there will be no India/Bharat!!
It's just like, we learn English to be connected & communicate at Global level.
I think, this is all anti-national political agenda😢. Maharashtra is one of a very respected state by all for it's "Unity in Diversity" kind of culture after India's independence!!
Many govt jobs give posting in different states. (IT jobs, etc also). Nobody can learn all Indian languages. 1 common Indian language is important.
Don't impose Hindi, Hindi is just official language not national language.i am a bengali.bengali is my mother tounge
HINDI.200.yeard.old.TAMIL.2000.years old.told.me.who.is.ancient.language
Then you have to learn Sanskrit or Bhojpuri (Successor of Prakrit) which are older than Tamil.
@@professionalsmunch3541 what is the script of Sanskrit its devanagari
whats the script of Hindi devanagari
so you imposing that script so its easy to push Hindi with Sanskrit
we know you northies malleolus intent
@@professionalsmunch3541 really? Sanskrit and Bhojpuri is older than south languages
thats good comedy
which script those languages written
when that script was created
Tamil Telugu are 3000 years old languages
@@professionalsmunch3541 Learn historty bro. Till now no one proved sanskrit is older then Tamil. Modi said tamil is the oldest Indian language. Learn history.
Tamil is a 2000 year old language, why is it limited to 1 state only. You are making Hindi as an enemy, but you are replacing Tamil with English.
BJP creates problems by.. Religion
Language
Now people forget about the failure in growth.. unemployment.. Rupee nosedive .. handcuffed deportation of Gurarathis, Punjabis,Haryana people..
How many languages taught in North India.. ??
It's India, and not 'Hindia'
Down with Union government and Three languages policy.
Down with Hindi authoritarianism, domination, Majoritarianism.
In Democracy alway majority is dominated. In this case Hindi speakers are in majority thats why India is a Hindia.
@@rsraja1403give us our land we know how to build our country.
@@rsraja1403
@rsraja1403
Brother,
This is exactly what the Tamil Nadu Government is against. . This is what they call Hindi speakers' hegemony, authoritarianism, domination, Majoritarianism in a federal structure. Tamil Nadu Government knows their rights.
Lol
Union Government should focus on improving the lives of people, develop the private sector, industries etc.. in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Jharkhand.
@@rsraja1403will shame hindia then
@@rsraja1403
All the Union governments and the rulers of UP, Bihar, Jharkhand purposely, cunningly and tactically did not educate, introduce English with their people. Under developed and per capita income less than 1L even after many years.
Think of them
Even captions / subtitles for this vedio has only hindi option. This is what "forcing" means. Paanparaag wale nahi samajte.😂
I could use the Auto Translate to English option
Exactly 💯
@@aeiphanes
I see all languages subtitles available now
😂😂😂
North Indians still selling hindi as national language 😂😂😂
They love to swim in their frog 🐸 sewages.
Dear paaji
Ur a shame to Punjabis
Am a Tamil I always have great respect for ur culture
Ur a shame
What shame? He spoke Right. Even bangladeshis speak and understand Hindi , why not who live in India speak Hindi?
@@rsraja1403😂😂😂 why I study hindi?
English is more benifit than hindi
@vijayakumar2967 it's nothing about benifits or loss . Hindi is most spoken language in India so.
@@rsraja1403not reqrd hindi is a north Indian language
@@rsraja1403 i dont know in what world the singh granpa is living because sril lanka is full of tamil and the next Is if the whole India learns english we can communicate with each other and other countries too why u guys trying say hindhi I didn't see any 3 language policy in north if they have 2 language policy mother tongue and english whole India is fine
The word Hindi itself is not Indian. Its 100% Persian. 90% of Hindi language is brought from Urdu, Persian, Turkish, Arabic. Just by giving a devanagiri script to it, you can not call Hindi as a Indian Language. Its high time, Indian Government should form a National Language Comittee and create an Unique Indian Language - combining equal portions of 6 of the Oldest Indian Classical Languages.
I think telugu should be national language
How can you say that Hindi is so much influenced by Persian, Urdu, Turkish and Arabic whereas I can talk to you for as long as I can with the entire vocabulary of Hindi without using any other languages. Yes the vocabulary may be influenced by Sanskrit but not by any other Muslim language❤.
People in north are often saying "hindi is bharat language unlike english"
But when i search about this in Google, it says
"Hindi ,sanskrit, urdu,english "- all belong to same language family called INDO EUROPEAN LANGUAGE FAMILY 😂😂
if people want to learn some TRUE bharat languages ,then they must learn TAMIL/TELUGU/KANNADA/MALAYALAM/TULU.
Bharat languages:
Tamil: Thaai (தாய்)
Kannada: Thaayi (ತಾಯಿ)
Telugu: Thalli (తల్లి)
Malayalam: Amma (അമ്മ)
Indo European languages:
English : mother.
Sanskrit: माता (mata)
Urdu : Maa(ماں)
Hindi : माँ(maan)
English is also an Indo-European, Does this make english as non -British language?
Isn't French a true language of France just because it comes under Indo-European language?
There is difference between European and Indo-European.
All Indo-Aryan languages are native languages of Indian subcontinent.
@@santosh18102 well said 👏
Many of the people who were interviewed has subconsciously forgot that they have sidelined their Mother tongue (Punjabi/Marathi/Gujarati/Marwari/ Braj Bhasha / Methi) , which would erode the lead to language extinction with in 2-3 generations.
@@homelesslavie_vlogs9600
brother, just because a Brother from a family settled in Europe, you cannot say " that brother doesn't belong to that family".
No matter how much you argue,you cannot deny the fact that hindi and english are cousin languages 😂😂😂
Lets together learn some bharat languages like Tamil/Telugu/kannada/malayalam which doesn't have any connection to European.
so why are u so concerning about hindhi rather than english because we can communicate to all the countries and with in each other
What's the use of asking people in Delhi ? For the people living in the Hindi heartland, hindi should be imposed on us because that's the language they're more fluent than English. Should the people of TN accept this just because things will be easier for the Majority hindi speakers, who has forgotten the importance of their mother tongue?
If you not forgotten your mother tounge when you learning English then how you forgot when you learning Hindi.
The level of ignorance is note worthy..😂😂
No body understood that India was united in what basis.
States were created on linguistic divide .
India doesn't have any official language .
He is right, sanskrit is a dead language.
Mara huga basha hi sanskrit???usko kyom pakkat kar bjp kaam kar raha hi
Sanskrit is still spoken
In south all the pandits use Verses in Sanskrit at temple
@@lesmonde4361 not true in Tamil Nadu
@lesmonde4361 so what??
I am from Andhra, no need to learn 3rd Indian language. Instead teach children how to take care of their finance. Most of us don't have any clue how to do the investments till we get married.
Finance is taught in colleges and not in school. You learn Marathi when you are coming to Maharashtra. Will you do that?
Bro, I live in USA for the past 15 years ,from Coimbatore. So many telugu family live here ,in fact my relative married to telugu boy and we accepted it coz he is from south. And we South Indians doing very well in USA. We are High paid and well educated,unlike North Indians . Who mostly are Bottom dwellers. So learning Hindi in very useless unless we want to sell panipuri in utter Pradesh.
@@abbys777 first save your marathi in maharastra😂😂😂😂😂.
@Attitudezero884 All languages are mine and I respect them. Nothing is your and mine. Hence you need to grow up.
Sister, this last brother from Chennai told us that local language is important but it seems that brother is not able to understand that if someone travels anywhere in India, then can he keep learning the language of that place?
He can manage with english.
@Attitudezero884 yes, you're absolutely right but my view is that all local languages should always be respected and promoted, but those languages that are being suppressed should also be uplifted.
Today it is being seen that Hindi is being totally rejected in the South. Well, this was fine till then, but even Sanskrit is being abused there.
I am from WEST BENGAL, we want 2 language policy don't want 3 language policy ✊🏻
Bhai tu phele bengal ko mamta ke changul se bacha fir language ke liye ladiyo aur tu to tamil nadu jaise state m rehta bhi nhi h gareeb state h tera agar hindu nhi padega to job kaise milega
@@immoralAryanhindi nhi Sikh k bhi bohot Bengali log south mei kam kr rha hai na thik waise hi milega moreover English is the best language to learn to communicate with all over the world.... hindi Sikh k v kuch fayeda nhi because central government has always been step parents types attitude towards west bengal.... tumlog toh khud south k language nhi sikhoge faltu mei logo ko pareshan kre ja rhe ho
@debosmitasar4158 1) first of all didi i am talking about the greater problem which is the manta problem nhi to adha bengal to gya h pura bengal bhi bangladesh ho jayega
2) may be kaam kar rhe h ho bengali log but don't u think opportunities in North are increasing compared to south and by 2/3 year north will have much more job opportunities than north
3) south have different language in every different state but north m aap kahi bhi hindi se communicate kar sakti ho
4) monetary terms me bhi agar soche to hindi ke paas much bigger audience h
5) language sikhne m 2-3 mahine lagta h maine khud telgue sikha h fir my gf to communicate well
6) 2 saal m aadmi 10-12 language sikh sakta h so don't fight over language
@@immoralAryan@I think You are brought up under Manuvaadi thought
West Bengal is the Most important State in Eastern Part
They are the Most tolerant. 60% Hindi Speaking People Living happily in West Bengal
They are Celebrating All Festivals without Any Heavy Security
@@immoralAryan1970 ke baad Kuchch Ghareeb State ke paas Paisa aa gaya Aise ghamand se bolte hain West Bengal Ghareeb State hai
Yeha ka Culture Rich hai
Yeha Kisi ko Non Veg Khaaney ya Veg Khaaney pr Maara ya Peeta nahi Jaata hai
Yeha Gobar se Holi Khelne waale bhi rah rahe hain aur Colour se Khelne Waale bhi
The questions asked were wrong and the amount of arrogance to call Hindi as the language of Bharat when south languages are older than Hindi and equally Indian is unbelievable!!! The audacity!!!
In 3 language policy, no imposition should be done. Mother tongue+ English+ any other language of your choice
Language is not qualification but just a means of the communication.
If multiple group of students in a north indian state wish for selecting 2 languages to learn, supposedly like telugu and marati, in most schools only hindi, sanskrit teachers are available, eventually the student doesn't have an option there. So they put peer pressure on the student even when they don't know what is peer pressure. The same applies when students from south indian state wish to learn any language like odiya and bhojpuri, they don't have other options except hindi and sanskrit.
Schools should improve to have adequate teachers well educated enough in that language to teach. That much amount of language teachers are not available to be appointed and produce good results in schools that are funded by state government in all states of India..
If this 2 language is working fine for a state and getting good results compared to other states, then it must be left to go on in progression that way. Stopping in between and changing it's course would require massive amount of workload for teachers and government & lot of study load to the children who are already good with what they have been learning.
That's the reason Tamil Nadu is not ready to accept NEP.
If there is need for a child's dream or a grown person's dream to be working in any state of India they can learn that language anytime. Basic need to communicate with world is English and to Let our roots be alive by Learning our mother tongue is enough for surviving and succeed.
Come on Indians of North, We South Indian states have Population and Area Similar to Many Countries. Just like how you told Hindi is Needed in Delhi like wise we say we need Kannada in Bengaluru, Tamil in Chennai.
Language imposition is wrong and this should never be supported as Our country is a very diverse country so each language should be respected and should be given importance, learning about others language is not a bad thing its actually good but the things it should voluntary it should never be imposed
The best thing in Maharashtra is we learn 3 language Marathi, Hindi and English ..the more you learn the mire you earn 😊
Hindi speaking belt people is less if we compare it with entire south n northeast India Even the hindi speaking people have different Dialect . Hindi is not our national language its one of the official languages and let it be .
8:44 which Mexican language?
Mexico has a rich linguistic diversity. While Spanish is the dominant language, the country officially recognizes 68 national languages, which include 364 linguistic variants.
Many of the people who were interviewed has subconsciously forgot that they have sidelined their Mother tongue (Punjabi/Marathi/Gujarati/Marwari/ Braj Bhasha / Methi) , which would erode the lead to language extinction with in 2-3 generations.
चाचा पढ़े-लिखे नहीं हैं। वे अपनी मातृभाषा में बात नहीं करते, बल्कि वैकल्पिक भाषा के रूप में हिंदी में बात करते हैं। इंटरव्यू हिंदी में होते हैं, अंग्रेजी नहीं।
First teach English in North Indian Government school students then they also develop obviously not radicalised by BJP.Then only they get some rationalism instead of Extremism and fascism
In bengluru and hyderabad in tech company majority from North India can speak english better than you
Tamilnadu support mother tongue .. And english.. ❤ from Tamilnadu
Only support tamil not English
😂😂😂 tamil support English..
Tragic comedy🤣
That Tamil boy rocked. 2 languages are fair enough. You didn't counter the people who mentioned Hindi as the National Language which is not at all true. We have 22 regional languages which include Hindi. Hence, don't impose any third language to anyone. Mother tongue and English are good enough. AI is advanced , communication would be much easier than we think in the next 1 decade. Teach them the technologies, science, etc instead inappropriate dominant mind set north regional languages.
English and hindi is the official language of India. Rest all are regional language
Uncle wants India to be like pakistan and bangladesh. 😅😅😅
You make india become srilanka
@Sid6219 No, we don't like chewing gutka and pan paraag and spit at parliament door like your brothers.🤣🤣🤣
@Vellayaanai we don't like try to remove saree of women mla in assembly
@@Sid6219 we dont frick monitor lizards
@@Sid6219it's done by that same shameless actress (JJ) who wanted to get sympathy from the public and started her political career
You are asking question to Delhi people who all says yes to HINDI. In north India any of government school will teach any of the south indian language as compulsory ? Will they accept to learn Malayalam/Tamil/kannada/Telugu? many of them will simply take as sanskrit/classic hindi as third language, which is similar to Hindi but they want south indian students to learn hindi . This is really you are spitting HINDI on us. You should have asked wil thy ready to learn south indian language as mandatory as third language? If not why they are asking us to learn Hindi mandatory? And just educate to those who think Hindi is our national language, that Hindi is not our national language. it's just an official language as English.
You cannot change the law for convenience. The Constitution does not grant Hindi supremacy over other languages. If you argue for Hindi imposition, have you ever read books in your own local languages like Maithili, Magahi, or Kannauji? Where did these languages go after Hindi became the dominant language in the Hindi belt?
In South India, our languages have a history spanning over 3,500 years. We continue to write poetry, novels, and songs in our native tongues, preserving our rich literary and cultural heritage. Language is an identity, not a hierarchy. Instead of imposing one language, respect and celebrate linguistic diversity.
But the law is made to learn the local language with hindu and english so north Indians will learn the local language or ur language?? I will learn my local language. Maybe people of up will learn Sanskrit or bhojpuri it is as simple as that
You can not change the law for convenience. The Constitution does not grant Hindi supremacy over other languages. If you argue for Hindi imposition, have you ever read books in your own local languages like Maithili, Magahi, or Kannauji? Where did these languages go after Hindi became the dominant language in the Hindi belt?
In South India, our languages have a history spanning over 3,500 years. We continue to write poetry, novels, and songs in our native tongues, preserving our rich literary and cultural heritage. Language is an identity, not a hierarchy. Instead of imposing one language, respect and celebrate linguistic diversity.
@@shyamn4817 Wouldn't it be more convenient? Do people from UP or Bihar only learn two languages? The three-language policy ensures that everyone gets a fair chance to learn their local language. Hindi, in particular, makes communication easier. Being born in Gujarat, I know Hindi, which gives me access to a much wider market, reaching audiences from Maharashtra to Bihar. If we focus only on local languages, what happens to market access? Unlike Europe, where each country has its own president or prime minister and functions independently in many aspects, India operates as a single nation. Even Modi Ji knows multiple languages-Gujarati, Hindi, English, and some Marathi. If every state becomes too rigid with its language, communication and governance will become challenging.
@@immoralAryan learn sanskrit but we should learn a seperate language no need. For your comfort we cannot learn hindi
Nowadays, everyone posts their opinions in the comment section mostly in English! So in the multilingual Indian Union, English can be the connecting language. Moreover, English is used more here than Hindi.
The Three language policy is to be imposed on Government schools which are run by the state government. Children already have so much to study. To impose a policy and not releasing funds for non-cooperation is a strong imposition.
Just because majority of them have been speaking Hindi… that dosent mean that we should also learn for their convenience…. All my life I’ve been using Tamil and English…..
Gujarathi.. punjabi… etc.. and other North Indian people don’t understand how hard this makes our lives
Tamil is as important as Hindi, just like every other regional language in India. Unlike many North Indian languages that evolved from Sanskrit and Prakrit, Tamil belongs to the Dravidian language family and has an independent linguistic heritage that predates Hindi. Learning multiple languages is always beneficial, but assuming that all Indians naturally know Hindi ignores India’s rich linguistic diversity. Tamil speakers valuing their language doesn’t mean they oppose learning others-it simply means they respect their roots, just as every linguistic community should
But bro half of the tamil literature comes from Sanskrit do not believe in me just do research
Secondly If anyone knows hindu it will increase the job potential inside India
3rd hindi with english is our official language
4th why did dmk sign for nep if they want to create so much Chaos??
5th- dmk follow periyar but Periyar said that tamil is the most barbaric language what about this
@ bro don’t just watch some RUclips videos and blindly follow them… this is why India today is in total denial of what we are lacking….. this control over the people of India since 2014 using social media is the reason…. China has reached so much heights…. We should focus on how we can achieve in things like that… instead too much importance is spent in learning Indian language….. I/ we truely believe learning extra languages is not going help our country become a superpower…. Our country lacks in many things see things outside what the media and social media narrates… pls u don’t know how we feel about this… always do deep dive…. Even the learning may be difficult to accept but pls be open to it and understand
@@monishkumar3948 first of all comparing with China is dumb because china follows one language which is mandarin and it is mandatory to learn mandarin all over china secondly india lacks in many things but it is our job to make it better "don't ask for what country did for u ask for what u did for the country"
3) learning multiple languages makes the mind Power strong
4th) people spend so much time on controversy instead of they spend time in learning a language it will definitely help to communicate better
5th)) if u know multiple languages there will be a better chance that the particular person can become the leader of the country
6) in terms of money it will be a blessing because if u have market access all over India there is no way ur business will shut down
@@immoralAryan lol learning multiple languages increases brain power says who a guy who learns only hindi and we know about north indians so called intelligence😂😂😂😂😂 they doesn't even learn the state language they stay in but we have to learn hindi for them. Lol if hindi increases opportunities why are north indians coming to our states in more number😂😂😂😂😂.
@Attitudezero884 North Indians won’t visit your state if you simply pass a law barring them from getting jobs there. Honestly,it’s not unusual for Tamil Nadu to have a separatist attitude-this is why the Annadurai government was dissolved under Chandrasekhar. Third, before the NEP, learning Hindi was actually compulsory, but now it’s optional; if you don’t believe me, just check the official document. Fourth, you’re so idle that you’ve left over 100 comments on this channel- I don’t know what’s up with this generation.
First fix the unhygienic environment, then talk about language debates....